Autumn budget 2025: Motorists urged not to fall foul of annual mileage rules

SelectCarLeasing_Mileage-2

Underestimating your annual mileage could invalidate your car insurance policy – and motorists have been warned about an incoming clamp-down.

Yearly mileage rules for drivers are set to come under increased scrutiny as part of the upcoming autumn budget.  

Reports suggest chancellor Rachel Reeves is planning to charge electric vehicle drivers 3p-per-mile, on top of other road taxes, with bills settled each year according to distances driven.   

Graham Conway, Managing Director at Select Car Leasing, suspects stricter oversight of annual mileages could trigger closer examination of odometer readings from insurance companies – and motorists should never attempt to ‘cheat the system’.  

Mr Conway explains: “The chancellor’s pay-per-mile plan is likely to put estimated annual mileages for drivers in the spotlight. And that heightened oversight should set alarm bells ringing for all motorists, no matter what sort of car they drive, when it comes to their insurance policies.  

“When you take out car insurance, you’re typically asked to estimate your annual mileage, with the figure provided influencing the size of your premium.  

“You might assume that insurance providers have no way of checking how many miles you’re actually travelling each year, but you’d be very wrong.  

“They can access the latest odometer readings from MOT data and sometimes have access to shared servicing information.  

“If you attempt to cheat the system by underestimating your annual mileage in order to lower the cost of your policy, you could end up having your policy voided for ‘misrepresentation’, particularly if you were to attempt to make a claim.  

“That leaves you open to being personally liable for repair costs, injuries, or third-party damages. You could even be accused of insurance fraud under the Consumer Insurance Act 2012 – something that could make cover much, much more expensive in the future.” 

If there’s a small difference between your estimated annual mileage and your real mileage, the matter is typically resolved via an adjustment to your insurance premium when you renew. 

More incorrect annual mileage estimates could result in refused claims and voided policies.  

Mr Conway adds: “When estimating your annual mileage, try and base it on real data. Have a look at old MOT certificates to find out how many miles you’re actually putting on the clock each year and round UP the figure, as opposed to under-cooking it, to give you plenty of wiggle room. 

“And remember that, from an insurance perspective, mileage is one of the most important indicators of risk.” 

Some policies, particularly for younger drivers, see vehicles fitted with a telematics ‘black box’ which automatically records mileage.  

Other policies can be taken out on a pay-per-mile basis and rely on a mileage-recording OBD device or connected car data.  

Research shows that around 16 percent of motorists have admitted providing false information to their insurance provider. Of this, 65 percent said that they had underreported their mileage to pay lower premiums.  

Mr Conway adds: “With driver mileages being monetised further with the proposed new EV tax, all motorists should anticipate more rigorous inspection from insurance companies, too.  

“We could see more regular odometer checks, mid-term premium hikes, charges for exceeding estimates, and increasing use of black boxes. That goes for all drivers, not just those behind the wheel of an EV. 

“Be honest with your annual mileage calculation – or prepare to face the consequences.”